This post sponsored by StageLightCompany.com—professional lighting for churches.
In this article, Duke DeJong shares the ins and outs of LED fixtures—the pros, cons, and concerns of LED lighting.
As recently as a few years ago when people mentioned getting some LEDs, that usually meant getting either PAR or strip-style fixtures with red, green, and blue diodes as the source of light instead of a conventional lamp. LED lighting has come far in the last 7 to 10 years, and you can find LED versions of nearly any style of fixture now. We’re seeing new moving wash and spot fixtures use LED diodes in addition to the growing number of different styles of wash lights (PAR, Fresnel, cyc/strip lights). In the last 18 months, we’ve even finally started to see some LED ellipsoidal fixtures coming available.
LED (Light Emitting Diode) technology has developed quickly over the last decade to become a very usable source of light in live performance. As this technology continues developing, newer and more sophisticated fixtures have been created to meet the needs of lighting designers. With more options than ever before, at very reasonable prices, LED fixtures are becoming common in most lighting systems.
Let’s look at some of the top reasons you could benefit from LED fixtures:
Low Power Consumption
Because LEDs draw a comparatively small amount of power, LEDs are an efficient way to get a high quantity of light with limited power. While one 20-amp circuit of power maxes out at four 500-watt PAR cans, you can power 20-40 of most LED PAR cans on the same amount of power.
LED fixtures can create a wide range of colors using anywhere from three to seven colors mixing together to create whatever color or color temperature of white you desire. LED fixtures with more colors available to mix with often can create richer, more accurate color and white light. But even a simple red, green, and blue-based fixture can provide more color light than a conventional fixture with a gel.
High Brightness For Colored Light
Conventional tungsten fixtures get color by putting a subtractive gel in front of the light. For example, R27 Medium Red from Rosco has a 4% transmission rate, meaning a red gel in front of a 1,000 watt lamp will spit out roughly 40 watts of light. LEDs give you light by adding intensity/light, therefore LED fixtures tend to produce much brighter color than conventional fixtures.
LED fixtures tend to have tens of thousands of hours of use time, versus 500-1,000 for most tungsten lamps. In other words, you’ll likely outgrow the fixture or have different needs before the fixture no longer produces light. Additionally, LEDs don’t burn out, so they are more durable and have lower maintenance.
Although LED stage lights do produce some heat (I’d say more like warmth), LED fixtures don’t begin to approach the heat of a conventional tungsten fixture. Venues lighting stage sets or people from the floor love this feature as they don’t have to be concerned about people touching the fixtures and burning themselves.
Small, Lightweight, and Portable
LED fixtures tend to be small, so they work great where space is tight or where you want light without being able to see the fixture. Being small also means most LED fixtures are lightweight and highly portable, a huge feature for churches who have to set up and tear down often.
Drawbacks of LED Fixtures
LED Ellipsoidal Fixtures Are Still High Cost
Due to the way most LEDs are arrayed together to produce light, LED fixtures have a harder time creating a focus-able beam like an ellipsoidal fixture can. Manufacturers are working hard to come up with solutions to this, however, and we’ve recently seen LED ellipsoidal offerings from ETC and Chauvet.
Some LED fixtures can produce millions of colors; unfortunately they can’t always produce the one you want. Due to the way colored LEDs are made, different LED fixtures have colors that they can’t quite replicate. The lack of a white light that looks great on human skin is often the number one complaint of LED fixtures, though we are seeing significant improvement as the technology develops. If there are specific colors or color temperatures that you have to have, you’ll be best served to test out the LED fixture you’re thinking about before you invest in too many of them.
Conventional Fixtures Still Output More White Light Per Dollar
LED lighting fixtures are bright for color, but aren’t quite as bright as a comparable conventional white fixture for white. As mentioned above, some lighting manufactures are making some great strides in producing a bright, controlled white light. But most still can’t compete with a 750-watt lamp in a Source 4 PAR or ellipsoidal.
Dimming Curve Issues
LEDs don’t use traditional powered dimming systems, so LED lights don’t behave the same as traditional lighting equipment when it comes to dimming. Cheaper units can have poor (steppy) dimming curves and there is the real possibility of high frequency flicker with cameras when using cheaper fixtures. With many LED fixtures, the light will snap to blackout unlike the cooling down of an incandescent filament. Although high-end LED fixtures can attempt to replicate it, LEDs also don’t naturally shift in color like a tungsten source does over its dimming range.
With LED fixtures, it’s very true that you get what you pay for. Most of the time, the cheaper the LED fixture, the more noticeable the flaws of LED are. My general preference is to purchase good to great quality LED fixtures from well-known, established manufacturers with a good track record of support. You’ll pay more for LED fixtures from manufacturers like ETC, Wybron, and Martin, but can have confidence that they’ll be great and be well supported. Elation/American DJ and Chauvet have also come a long way in the past 5-8 years, really stepping up their quality and support while still providing cost-effective lighting solutions.
Are LED Fixtures Right for You?
Unfortunately, as with most questions, the answer is “it depends.” Most of the lighting systems we design these days include a mixture of conventional tungsten and LED fixtures for a variety of reasons. It really does depend on what kind of power and infrastructure you have available, what kind of light you need, and what your budget is.
Duke is passionate about equipping the next generation of ministry leaders, especially those serving churches with technology. He serves as Church Relations Director for CCI Solutions, a design build technology solutions provider. Follow Duke on Twitter: @dukedejong